Maxing out Roths with a balance transfer
One of our goals for 2006 is to not only make the maximum allowable contributions to our retirement accounts, but to do it as aggressively as possible at the beginning of the year to maximize our long-term gains.
One of the ways we are accomplishing this is by having adjusted the husband’s SIMPLE IRA contributions so that he maxes out by the end of June (at which point he should have a new job). Roughly half of his paycheck is now going straight to Vanguard.
Another strategy we were kicking around was possibly utilizing a no-fee, 0% balance transfer offer to immediately make the maximum contributions to each of our Roth IRAs at the beginning of the year. In a previous post we briefly touched upon the idea and our reasoning for doing so.
Ultimately, we decided against this strategy this year primarily for two reasons:
We still plan to be aggressive with our contributions and should be able to max out both Roths far more quickly than last year, especially now that our primary incomes have increased. Next year will be a more opportune time to use the balance transfer strategy to max out the Roths because we’ll have the transferred balance of student loan #2 paid off and have much more available credit.
One of the ways we are accomplishing this is by having adjusted the husband’s SIMPLE IRA contributions so that he maxes out by the end of June (at which point he should have a new job). Roughly half of his paycheck is now going straight to Vanguard.
Another strategy we were kicking around was possibly utilizing a no-fee, 0% balance transfer offer to immediately make the maximum contributions to each of our Roth IRAs at the beginning of the year. In a previous post we briefly touched upon the idea and our reasoning for doing so.
Ultimately, we decided against this strategy this year primarily for two reasons:
- We are planning to use a no-fee, 0% balance transfer offer in the very near future to completely pay off student loan #2. Combine this with the fact that we already have the 2.99% lifetime balance transfer we are currently paying down with American Express, we’re just not comfortable introducing another source of debt at this stage. Our preference is to have no more than two balance transfers at any one time.
- Even though we are making great progress each month, we’re still not satisfied with our amount of available credit. To max out both Roths would certainly push our credit utilization well above 50%.
We still plan to be aggressive with our contributions and should be able to max out both Roths far more quickly than last year, especially now that our primary incomes have increased. Next year will be a more opportune time to use the balance transfer strategy to max out the Roths because we’ll have the transferred balance of student loan #2 paid off and have much more available credit.



4 Comments:
Just ran across your blog, so I apologize if I'm missing something here, but why are you so concerned about your student loan debt when you have have other higher interest debt such as the credit cards or even your second mortgage. Also the student loan interest is tax deductable.
Also was curious as to why your student loans were at different rates. I consolodated both my student loans and my wife's student loans into one loan a little over a year ago and locked both of them in at 2.82%, which personally I've made the decision to pay off as absolutely slow as possible. I realize rates have gone up quite a bit since then but you should still be able to consolodate both of those loans at roughly 4-5%.
Again not questioning your motives as there is likely something I don't know about your situation, just was curious as to why you were as concerned about your student loans.
Best of luck to you
My Financial Journey
By
MyFinancialJourney, at 2/20/2006 5:21 AM
Hello, the questions you asked have been covered here in the past, but to quickly address your immediate concerns:
The plan is to pay off student loan #2 AND the second mortgage as quickly as possible while at the same time maxing out our retirement accounts and finish establishing our cash reserve. A quick glance at our goals and balance sheet explanation (links on the right) should help to make things more clear.
The only credit debt we carry month-to-month is a transferred balance on the American Express Blue card at 2.99% for life; all other accounts are paid in full each month, so there is no high-interest debt accumulating here.
Just because we get a tax deduction on student loan #2 doesn’t make it alright to keep it around. For the typical American taxpayer who pays in the 28% tax bracket, the deduction amounts to a rebate of twenty eight cents for every dollar paid in interest. Yes, better than nothing, but not exactly a free lunch either.
It would probably make more sense to get rid of the second mortgage first since it is at a higher rate, but that debt is 6 times larger and would take a lot longer to pay down. We’d rather go ahead and quickly unload the student loan #2 debt from our backs and then focus our attention on the second mortgage.
Also, another thing to keep in mind is that the student loan #2 interest rate is variable, and with short-term interest rates on the rise recently we are only hurting ourselves by keeping this debt around. It could potentially be at a higher rate than the second mortgage in the future and we don’t want to risk that happening.
Student loan #1 was consolidated after the wife finished college. Student loan #2 can not be consolidated because it is a private loan. Because one cannot reconsolidate a student loan to get a new rate, we are stuck with what we have. Yeah, I wish we could have the rate you got, but with rate locking its all about timing and yours was much better than ours in this case.
Hope this helps and thanks for reading!
By
Brian, at 2/20/2006 7:29 AM
Clears it up perfectly and I understand much better now that I know the background (my fault for being lazy and not reading other posts first)
Thanks and good luck,
My Financial Journey
By
My Financial Journey, at 2/20/2006 8:08 AM
No problem, I look forward to seeing any future feedback or answering any questions from you in the future.
By
Brian, at 2/20/2006 8:22 AM
Post a Comment
<< Home